top of page

Powerful Persuasion: Mastering the Art of Disagreeing with Those Above You

Updated: Jun 23, 2023

In professional environments, it's not uncommon to find yourself at odds with someone in a higher position. While it may feel daunting to voice your views, it's essential to foster a culture of open dialogue and constructive discussion. So, how do you approach such situations? When should you speak up, and how can you effectively express your differing opinions? Let's explore valuable insights that will help you navigate these challenging conversations with professionalism, positivity, and support.

  1. Assessing the Risks: Realistic perspectives for productive disagreements. it's natural to magnify the potential risks of disagreeing with someone more powerful. However, it's crucial to objectively evaluate both the risks of speaking up and the consequences of staying silent. By considering the possible negative implications of not expressing your viewpoint, such as derailing a project or compromising trust within the team, you can make a well-informed decision.

  2. Timing is Key: Deciding when to speak up. Sometimes, it's best to gather your thoughts and wait before voicing your disagreement. This is particularly relevant if you need more time to fully understand the issue at hand or if you anticipate support from others who might share a similar view. Additionally, choosing a private setting for the discussion can help the powerful person feel less threatened and more open to differing perspectives.

  3. Building bridges through shared goals: Before expressing your disagreement, take a moment to understand what matters to the person in a position of power. By connecting your viewpoint to a shared objective, such as team credibility or timely project completion, you increase the likelihood of being heard. It's essential to explicitly state the connection to the common goal, highlighting that your intention is to collaborate and advance shared interests rather than create conflict.

  4. Permission to Disagree: Balancing respect and assertiveness. Requesting permission to voice your dissent might seem deferential, but it actually demonstrates respect and allows the powerful person to feel psychologically safe and in control. You can approach the conversation by saying, "I have reasons to believe our current approach may not work. May I present my perspective and reasoning?" By giving them the choice to engage in the discussion, you empower yourself to express your disagreement more confidently.

  5. Staying Calm: The power of composure. Maintaining a calm and composed demeanour is crucial when expressing disagreement. Even if your heart is racing, strive to present your thoughts neutrally and deliberately. Avoid body language or speech patterns that convey anxiety or reluctance, as they can undermine your message. Taking deep breaths and speaking at a moderate pace projects confidence and helps create a calm atmosphere for both parties involved.

  6. Acknowledging the Original Point: Laying the foundation for constructive dialogue. When presenting your dissent, it's essential to start by clearly articulating the other person's perspective or decision. This demonstrates your understanding and establishes a solid foundation for discussion. By exceeding their expectations by accurately summarising their viewpoint, you set the stage for a productive exchange of ideas.

  7. Language Matters: Facts over judgements. Be mindful of your language when expressing concerns. Avoid using judgmental words like "short-sighted," "thoughtless", as they can provoke negative reactions. Instead, focus on presenting factual information to support your viewpoint. For example, rather than saying, "I think the first-quarter deadline is naive," you can say, "Based on our past experiences, completing similar projects within that timeframe has been challenging due to specific circumstances." Stay neutral, highlight the problem, and aim for an honest and worthwhile exchange of ideas.

  8. Embrace Humility: When expressing your opinions, remember that they are based on your own viewpoint and should not be presented as the only truth. Embrace curiosity and invite the group to share their perspectives, using phrases like "I'm thinking aloud here." Foster a collaborative environment where diverse ideas can be explored and valued. Bringing everyone into the conversation opens the floor for the conversation to go two ways, your way or being open to critique.

  9. Recognise their authority: While the person in power will ultimately make the decision, it's important to acknowledge their role. You can say, "I understand you have the final say. This decision is in your hands." This demonstrates your awareness of their position and reminds them that they have options. However, it's crucial to maintain your own self-respect by not retracting your opinion or offering insincere praise. Balancing respect for their authority with your own integrity is key.

Embrace the Power of Positive Intentions:

  • Recognise that disagreements stem from diverse perspectives and a genuine desire to find the best solution.

  • View others as collaborators rather than adversaries, believing that they have the team's or organisation's best interests at heart.

  • Approach conversations with empathy and a willingness to understand different viewpoints.

  • Focus on building understanding and finding common ground rather than winning arguments.

  • Actively listen, show empathy, and value diverse perspectives.

  • Cultivate a culture of respect, cooperation, and inclusivity, fostering an environment where diverse perspectives can thrive.

47 views0 comments


bottom of page